Introduction
We now look at how a reduction in energy use can be achieved, first of all in buildings. We will consider the legislation and political drive to create buildings that are carbon neutral. There are a number of measures that can be taken to make any building more energy efficient, but it is also important to design a new building to exploit natural energy resources. The effectiveness of the design can be evaluated by subsequently monitoring energy performance.
The Zero Energy Building
Energy use in a zero energy building (ZEB) is minimised and all the energy consumed must originate from a renewable source. However, this does not imply energy rationing or utility independence. Such homes are also referred to as ‘zero carbon’ or ‘carbon neutral’, though the latter term more accurately refers to an individual. A ‘green building’, or ‘eco building’ will include measures to reduce environmental impact, but not to the extent of achieving zero carbon performance.
A large portion of the energy used in the UK is within buildings, and the UK government has identified that CO2 emission reductions in this sector can be readily made. By 2025 the Government will introduce a Future Homes Standard for new build homes to be future-proofed with low carbon heating and world-leading levels of energy efficiency. By making our homes and other buildings more energy efficient and embracing smart and low carbon technologies, we can improve the energy efficiency of peoples’ homes and boost economic growth while meeting our targets for carbon reduction. (Fig. 1)
Housing Minister Rt Hon Christopher Pincher MP said: 19th Jan. 2021
- Improving the energy performance of buildings is vital to achieving net-zero emissions by 2050 and protecting the environment for future generations to come.
- The radical new standards announced today will not only improve energy efficiency of existing homes and other buildings, but will also ensure our new homes are fit for the future, by reducing emissions from new homes by at least 75%.
- This will help deliver greener homes and buildings, as well as reducing energy bills for hard-working families and businesses.
Future Homes Standard Proposal
- From 2025, new homes built to the Future Homes Standard will have carbon dioxide emissions at least 75% lower than those built to current Building Regulations standards.
- Introducing the Future Homes Standard will ensure that the homes this country needs will be fit for the future, better for the environment and affordable for consumers to heat, with low carbon heating and very high fabric standards.
- All homes will be ‘zero carbon ready’, becoming zero carbon homes over time as the electricity grid decarbonises, without the need for further costly retrofitting work.
Figure 1: Governments Proposals (Public domain)
The Government has dual ambitions of achieving net zero emissions by 2050 and continuing progress towards achieving 300,000 homes a year by the mid-2020s. These objectives are not mutually exclusive, and with good planning and smart design we can build the homes we need while protecting and enhancing the natural environment and adjusting to climate change.
The introduction of the Future Homes Standard will ensure that an average home will produce at least 75% lower CO2 emissions than one built to current energy efficiency requirements. In the short term this represents a considerable improvement in the energy efficiency standards for new homes. Homes built under the Future Homes Standard will be ‘zero carbon ready’, which means that in the longer term, no further retrofit work for energy efficiency will be necessary to enable them to become zero-carbon homes as the electricity grid continues to decarbonise.
Homes built under the Future Homes Standard will be future-proofed with low carbon heating and world-leading levels of energy efficiency. By delivering carbon reductions through the fabric and building services in a home rather than relying on wider carbon offsetting, the Future Homes Standard will ensure new homes have a smaller carbon footprint than any previous Government policy.
Though there is much legislation, there is also the barrier that many of the measures required to make a building greener also tend make the building more expensive.
Activity 1
- Will initiatives to generate electricity on a massive scale by renewable means not automatically make all buildings zero energy?
- Is zero carbon buildings an objective and does planting additional forestry encourage carbon neutrality?
- Discuss the definition of a zero energy building?
- What is an Energy Performance Certificate?
Solution
a.
In a sense large-scale renewable energy generation does make all homes carbon neutral, but the point is to speed up progress towards global carbon emission reductions by attacking the problem from another direction. There are dual roles of reducing energy consumption and possibly incorporating micro-renewables into the design. Zero energy buildings are not an end in themselves, but valuable only in their contribution to a reduction in the emission of greenhouse gases.
b.
Whilst planting additional forests to balance existing carbon emission does result in carbon neutrality, the action demonstrates a basic confusion between goals and objectives. The goal is to mitigate global climate change. Achieving a zero carbon building is an objective. It would be preferable for the building to be made carbon neutral, and growing trees as an additional action that separately contributes to climate change mitigation. Carbon neutrality as a goal is arbitrary and generally meaningless.
c.
The Zero Energy Building can be defined in many different ways because of the relationship between the building and the residents—buildings only consume energy by virtue of the occupants. And indirect energy usage may or may not be counted. For example, should the energy used travelling between the building and work be included? A building sited close to the work place will save energy because of its location. Some consider that off-site renewable energy cannot be counted. And what about energy used in the construction and manufacturing and transporting the materials?
But in a sense, this is very pedantic because zero energy is an arbitrary objective. It is the contribution to climate change mitigation that is important, and really net energy generation is even better. This is a problem with current legislation that gives relief from stamp duty if a house is zero energy. The target must be met, but a ZEB is just a label; significantly reducing emissions but missing the ZEB target by a small amount should also be encouraged.
d.
An Energy Performance Certificate (EPC) is a four-page document which sets out the energy efficiency of a property on a traffic light system of A (most efficient) to G (least efficient) and is valid for 10 years. It is needed whenever a property is: Built, Sold, or Rented.
An EPC contains information about a property’s energy use and typical energy costs, and recommendations about how to reduce energy use and save money.
Shown below is an example of an EPC.
Figure 2: [source] (public domain)
Energy Saving Measures in the Home
There are many different measures that can be taken to limit energy use and eliminate profligacy, but it is first important to assess how energy is currently being used by conducting an energy audit. The space heating (and cooling) requirement is the most important consideration because of the amount of energy used for heating. It is desirable to have a thermostat in each room set at a level which is comfortable but not unnecessarily hot. A temperature of 25 oC is hot, but 18 oC is tolerable, and there is a big difference in the energy needed to keep the temperature at 18 oC compared to 25 oC. As a general rule, about 1 % of the total energy used in a building is saved with each degree the temperature is lowered. By experimenting with different settings it should be possible to agree a temperature everyone in the house can accept.
But a heating system is only needed because heat in the home is eventually lost to the outside. To virtually eliminate heating cost, the rule is pretty simple; as far as possible create a sealed box covered by a thick blanket of insulation. This means closing vents and gaps (though this might not be feasible where cavity circulation is necessary to clear moisture ingress). But air circulation is needed for comfort (and safety in the case of fires and boilers to clear dangerous products of combustion), hence energy loss becomes inevitable without sophisticated heat reclamation. Nevertheless sensible measures should be taken wherever possible. Ensure open fires are made efficient (Fig. 3), or replace open fires with central heating (Fig. 4). If there is a choice, install underfloor heating because the circulating water is at a lower temperature than with radiator systems making the boiler run more efficiently.
Figure 3: Open fires actually cool a house by drawing air through the building to fill the lower pressure region that forms around the fire because of convection. And much of the energy in the fire can be lost through the flue or chimney. Efficiency is 20%, but even less when the cooling effect of the draught is included. A stove or burner as shown above will be more efficient [source] (public domain)
Figure 4: Unlike older radiator systems (image), modern central heating systems are installed with the connecting pipes hidden behind walls or located in the floor cavity. It will be preferable for the pipes to be visible and run along walls. Energy is wasted when pipes cut through the protective skin of the house. [source] (public domain)
Replace older boilers with a combination or 'combi' boiler which is both a high efficiency water heater and a central heating boiler in a single compact unit. Combi boilers heat water directly from the mains when you turn on a tap, so you won't need a hot water storage cylinder or a cold water storage tank in the roof space.
Heat rises, so 25% of heat can be lost through the roof area. By insulating the roof, much more heat is retained within the property, which can significantly reduce your heating bill. There are natural and manufactured materials available, some of which can be installed by the home owner; others require a contractor with specialist equipment for installation.
Different materials have different ‘U-values’ relating to its insulating properties, the lower the U-value the slower the rate of heat loss (i.e. materials with a low U-value are the best insulators). Thermal transmittance, also known as U-value, is the rate of transfer of heat through a structure (which can be a single material or a composite), divided by the difference in temperature across that structure. The units of measurement are W/m²K. The better-insulated a structure is, the lower the U-value will be. Workmanship and installation standards can strongly affect the thermal transmittance. If insulation is fitted poorly, with gaps and cold bridges, then the thermal transmittance can be considerably higher than desired. Thermal transmittance takes heat loss due to conduction, convection and radiation into account.
As you are unable to see cavity wall insulation there is no simple way of checking that it has been done properly. You should use a contractor who will issue a cavity wall guarantee certificate produced by the Cavity Insulation Guarantee Agency (CIGA), which covers the work standards and materials used [https://ciga.co.uk/] within 25 years from the installation date.
Activity 2
(a) Conduct an audit of how energy is used in your home and how energy use could be reduced. Consider lighting, washing clothes, drying clothes, showers and baths, cooking, cooling, insulation, draughts, type of heating used, temperature of rooms, appliances, glazing. Remember cost is not the issue but energy used, though actions could be grouped by cost.
Solution
a.
There are many measures that could be taken. A number are listed below (largely common sense):
Figure 5: Thermal energy losses in a building [source] used under fair dealing.
- Wash clothing at 30 oC
- Run the washing machine or dishwasher with full loads
- Avoid tumble drying – dry clothes outdoors when possible
- Defrost your freezer regularly and avoid putting hot food in the freezer
- Turn down your thermostat and immersion heater temperature by one degree
- Boil a kettle with only as much water as you need
- Cover pots and pans when cooking – they will boil a lot quicker
- Use rechargeable
- Use energy efficient light bulbs
- Control light with motion detectors
- Buy appliances showing the Energy Saving Recommended label
- Look for European Union (EU) energy labels on fridges, freezers and washing machines (A is most efficient and G is least efficient)
- Install roof and wall insulation
- Add an additional layer of insulation
- Install double glazing
- Draw heavy curtains across windows at dusk
- Increase the air gap in all double glazing, or install triple glazing
- Use radiator valves with thermostats included
- Use electronic timers
- Learn how the boiler / CH controls work
- Insulate the hot-water tank
- Lag pipes
- Put draught-proofing strips round windows and doors—warm air going out balances cold air coming in
- Consider under-floor insulation
- Take a shower instead of a bath
- Reduce the time taken to shower
- Pressure cookers and microwaves are cheaper to run than a conventional oven or hob.
- Spin clothes before tumble-drying.
- Use the most appropriate setting on your tumble dryer.
- Fix dripping taps.
- Put the plug in the wash hand basin - don't waste hot water.
- Always turn lights off when you leave a room
- Don’t buy unnecessary appliances and gadgets
- Don’t leave charging transformers powered on
- Don’t leave equipment on standby
- Switch on the computer after use (computers that start instantly would save energy)
New Building Design
When a new building is planned there is an opportunity to incorporate green features into the design. There are a variety of external services available to the architect, but simulation and analysis software tools can be used in-house to calculate the effect of specific design changes on the model and thereby optimise the design. This will also ensure the design conforms with the tightening legislation governing building performance.
The building orientation and shape can be altered to accommodate PV arrays or solar hot water, wind turbines attached with due consideration to noise and the effect of vibration on the structure of the building, and a heat pump may be installed on site. By linking to geographical information systems, weather data, and perhaps data acquired during a site survey, the influence of the microclimate can be factored into the design.
Passive measures can also be adopted to exploit incident sunlight. A passive house will trap solar energy and move the heat about in a natural way to equalise temperature and remove steep thermal gradients. Daylight is used to reduce the need for artificial illumination (Fig. 6). Skylights can be used to bring daylight into the centre of rooms when privacy is needed or wall space is limited: Light pipes (or fibre optical bundles) can transmit light from the roof into a disconnected room (Fig. 7).
Figure 7: The Solatube daylighting system [source] used under fair dealing.
Figure 6: The ’eco-gherkin’ building in London. An example of environmental design [source] (CC BY-SA 2.0)
Natural light is used for illumination as far as possible. Sunlight creates a feeling of well-being (vitamin D), attunes the body and mind with the seasons and can contribute to restful sleep.
Another important design feature of this building is the ability to use the energy about. There is emphasis on natural ventilation with the building mimicking a living breathing entity.
Buildings are designed in such a way that glazing faces the full southern sun in winter when energy is most needed. The house should be located away for obstructions. Glass should have a solar heat gain coefficient (SHGC), between 0 and 1. This is a measure at how effectively sunlight is converted to internal heat. In Scotland, glass ideally should be around a SHGC value of 0.75 or higher to compensate for respective environmental conditions.
Alternatively, the Scottish Building Standards Agency say that windows must have a U-value (thermal insulation rating) of not more than 1.8 W/m2K.
Overglazing should be avoided: The building will be too hot in summer and too cold in winter. Materials with a high thermal mass should be used for construction and placed in the path of direct sunlight.
When buying a house it is extremely rare to find one that ticks all the boxes. One way to get the ideal home is to start from scratch, and this can be profitable too. If the new build is environmentally friendly and generates more power than it needs, the excess energy can be sold back to suppliers without incurring income tax or capital gains tax. Grants for microgenerators, central heating and insulation make the prospect even more appealing, especially with value added tax cut of 5 to 17.5 per cent on a range of energy-saving products.
Under the UK Government’s Renewable Heat Incentive (RHI) you are entitled to receive quarterly cash payments over seven years if you install an eligible renewable heating technology such as a heat pump (air source or ground source) or solar thermal (hot water) system. The RHI will reduce your payback period considerably and in some cases will cover the cost of installation.
Government grants of up to £2,500 per UK household are available for the installation of microgeneration technologies through the Department for Business Enterprise and Regulatory Reform's Low Carbon Buildings Programme. Grants can contribute to the cost of installing a certified product by a certified installer and the technologies supported include:
- Solar photovoltaics
- Wind turbines
- Solar thermal hot water
- Ground source heat pumps
- Small hydro
- Fuel cells
- Bio-energy
- Renewable CHP (combined heat and power)
- MicroCHP
In Scotland, the croft house grant scheme can help crofters build new homes. Rates of grant vary depending on where the croft is located but can be up to £22,000, with high priority going to remote areas with declining populations.
Activity 3
- How can different types of glass have such a wide range of properties? List the main 4 types of flat glass?
- Can existing older buildings be adapted (retrofitted) to incorporate passive house standards?
Solution
a.
Glass is not just one substance but the name for a class of materials whose properties vary with the type and quantity of the chemicals combined in the mix. The composition of ‘ordinary’ glass is shown on the right. It is basically sand (silica), but other minerals and chemicals are added to improve the properties. Sodium Oxide is added to reduce the melting temperature; Calcium, magnesium and aluminium oxides are added to make the glass non-water soluble.
The four main types of flat glass are;
1) Annealed Glass
2) Heat Strengthened Glass
3) Tempered or Toughened Glass
4) Laminated Glass
Formula for common glass:
70% - 74% SiO2 (silica)
12% - 16% Na2O (sodium oxide)
5% - 11% CaO (calcium oxide)
1% - 3% MgO (magnesiumA full description of these are available online [https://www.basystems.co.uk/blog/2016/10/glass-types/]
b.
In the past, the scope of green renovation projects was somewhat limited. To be sure, you could always purchase a weatherizing kit to stop the drafts from around your windows and doors. But, the building envelope of many older homes was often seen as too compromised to make meaningful gains in terms of energy efficiency. In terms of thermal bridging, some older homes have frames that don't allow for maximum airtightness. If foundation issues are present, thermal bridging at the wall-to-floor junction can also be challenging. If your older home has very small rooms, thickening the walls to increase the insulation might not be feasible. New builds were seen as necessary if you were to achieve high thermal comfort levels with a radically reduced energy consumption.
Of course, the particular retrofit strategy will differ according to the specifics of each home. three key factors that affect building cost: Complexity of the design, Level of finishing, and Size. For a house to receive a recognised certificate, it must include some of the following sustainable building criteria:
- reduction of thermal bridges
- improved thermal insulation
- considerably improved airtightness
- use of high quality, energy-efficient windows
- efficient heat generation
- ventilation with highly efficient heat recovery
- use of renewable energy sources
So, for a £250,000 home, you might be looking at upwards of £75,000 in renovations. Now, let's imagine that you were able to reduce your utility bills by 90%. If you were paying around £200 per month on gas and electricity, you could expect yearly savings of almost £2,200. Just looking at that equation alone, it would take about 30 years to pay off the investment - but the payback becomes much quicker in areas with high energy costs and long winters. While this long a payback may sound unappealing from a financial perspective, it is not the full picture. The analysis also must include two additional factors: Increased Home Valuation, and Home Comfort
Energy Monitoring and Non – Residential Buildings
Energy monitoring in residential buildings often amounts to no more than keeping an eye on the quarterly bills or installing a smart meter . This is fine when it is easy to control and limit energy use. However in a non-residential building, the people with the responsibility for controlling energy use cannot go around switching off lights and turning down the heating. The energy transfer processes in a large building are very complex and environmental parameters such as temperature and air quality should be under the control of an automated Building Energy Management System (BEMS).
The BEMS sensors can also be used to monitor how the building is performing, or a separate network of sensors can be installed. It is important to monitor the temperature and energy performance of a building to check if the building functions according to its design, with any discrepancy feeding into and improving on the design process. Buildings also degrade over time and information from monitoring systems can be used to trigger repairs and improvements.
A building may be continuously monitored with a permanently installed sensor network, or can be periodically surveyed by attaching sensors to the flow and return pipes of the heating system, recording the data captured at regular intervals with a data logger. The data can be processed later with reference to the measured room temperature to understand energy demand as a function of space and time. From this the BEMS may be reconfigured to reduce energy use and improve efficiency.
Figure 8: Green Building Design; Bosco Verticale (Milan, Italy) [source] (CC BY 3.0)
Non-residential buildings can be more energy efficient than domestic buildings because of their size difference, but are subject to more rigid legislative controls. There are rules governing air quality, temperature, acoustic emissions and illumination that may be in direct conflict with the desire to reduce energy use.
Figure 9: PV Solar panels situated on roof of commercial building. Making use of wasted space [source] (public domain)
In many cases the design will be more complex because of the additional constraints. Indoor Air Quality (IAQ) is an important issue which should be recognised in current designs. Indoor Air Quality refers to the air quality within and around buildings and structures, especially as it relates to the health and comfort of building occupants. Understanding and controlling common pollutants indoors can help reduce your risk of indoor health concerns. Health effects from indoor air pollutants may be experienced soon after exposure, or possibly, years later.
But with new non-residential (commercial) designs, the architect has the opportunity to experiment with medium-scale energy generation measures that would just be inappropriate in the design of a residential building (Fig. 8): Large ground source heat pumps can be installed; medium-sized wind turbines can be used (10-75 kW) - at these generation capacities turbines become very economic; ventilation heat recovery becomes viable; PV panels may also be included. It becomes necessary to understand the ways new and renewable energy sources can be harnessed in buildings, and modelling must be used effectively to get a credible understanding of how the building will work. These skills are increasingly in demand in architecture and engineering consultancies, building analysis and design consultancies, utilities and regulatory organisations, local and national government, and academia.
Activity 4
- What is a Building Energy Management System and how does it work?
- What design methodologies should be followed when trying to incorporate renewable energy into new private and public buildings?
Solution
a.
Building Energy Management Systems (BEMS) are integrated, computerised systems for monitoring and controlling energy-related building services plant and equipment such as heating, ventilation and air conditioning (HVAC) systems, lighting, power systems and so on.
BEMS provide real-time remote monitoring and integrated control of a wide range of connected systems, allowing modes of operation, energy use, environmental conditions and so on to be monitored and allowing hours of operation, set points and so on to be adjusted to optimise performance and comfort. BEMS can also trigger alarms, in some cases predicting problems and informing maintenance programmes. They allow records to be kept of historical performance, enable benchmarking of performance against other buildings or sites and may help automate report writing.
BEMS can be independent installations with separate maintenance contracts, or manufacturer installations which include maintenance. They can be wired or wireless systems. BEMS may have remote outstations that can be interrogated locally, or may be accessible from mobile devices. However, major buildings may be vulnerable to cyber attack, especially when they are associated with prominent organisations.
Figure 11: Typical BEMS System [source] used under fair dealing.
b.
To create a sustainable building, it is recommended to;
- Choices of materials and construction methods
- Insulating the building envelope
- Designing for energy efficient deconstruction and recycling of materials
- Designing for low energy intensive transportation
- Developing energy efficient technological processes
- Use of passive energy design
- Material Conservation
- Design for Waste Minimization
- Reducing and recovering construction waste
- Reuse and Recycling
- The storage and disposal of construction waste
- Design for Pollution prevention
- Water Conservation
- Utilizing water-efficient plumbing fixtures
- Design for dual plumbing
- Collecting rainwater using rainwater and grey water storage
- Employ re-circulating systems
- Designing low-demand landscaping
- Pressure Reduction
If you have enjoyed this topic and wish to read further, more notes can be found by following the link below. You will require Microsoft Publisher to open the file: